“The Debate” – FOCUS online Revamps its Comments Section

Anger, insinuations, division: Online comment sections often bring out the worst in people. FOCUS online receives more than 500,000 reader comments every month. Instead of hiding them, the editorial team has turned them into a regular feature: “The Debate.” Since then, the comments have become more substantive. What happened there?

Nov 16, 2026 6 min. reading time

“The internet trolls have won. Sorry, there’s not much you can do about it.” Eight years ago, The New York Times summed up the situation regarding reader comments with this headline. At best, critics limited themselves to expressions of disapproval along the lines of “I’ve always enjoyed reading your newspaper, until …”. At worst, they sent death threats. So much for the cliché.

Some media outlets are discussing whether to disable the comment feature entirely, while others have already done so because they could no longer keep up with moderating the flood of trolls. Yet FOCUS online has spotted an opportunity in this dark corner of the internet, of all places.

“I’ve noticed that comments add value to journalistic content in particular,” says Pascal Deutschländer. “Maybe it’s because I’m not a journalist. No one has posted nasty comments under my articles.” Deutschländer is the GenAI product manager at Burda Media. “It was actually the App Store that got me thinking,” he says. Because in the App Store, comments are one thing above all else: valuable feedback from the community. Reports of bugs, requests from app users, ideas for new features. Couldn’t something valuable also be derived from the comments section on FOCUS online?

AI Helps Analyze the Comments

In conversations with colleagues, Deutschländer realizes that they are all pondering the same question. More than half a million reader comments accumulate every month on FOCUS online—an untapped treasure trove. What if these comments were collected and curated to further the discussion?

In 2025, this idea gave rise to a concrete format: “The Debate.” To bring it to life, Deutschländer and his team built an AI tool that scans the comment sections on FOCUS online for discussions and curates them on a dashboard. With the help of the tool, two editors assess which articles are the subject of particularly intense discussion. The topics range from soccer and expensive french fries at the swimming pool to pensions, Russia, and immigration policy.

The AI summarizes the debate, identifies particularly relevant voices, and visualizes the range of opinions. This content is then reviewed, evaluated, and edited by the editorial staff. Without AI, the sheer volume of comments would be impossible to analyze, but in the end, a human always decides what gets published. The result is an article that reflects the sentiment expressed in the comments and highlights particularly interesting quotes.

Reader Engagement is a Testament to the Format’s Success

The format quickly became a hit. “The Debate” brought FOCUS online a wider reach, and search engine algorithms boosted the format. And readers love it: they spend more time on the “Debate” articles than on most other posts. In a study, the Burda team investigated what motivates readers most to read the comments section and post their own comments there. “Most people want to see where they stand. They want to know if they’re alone in their opinion and what others are saying,” explains Deutschländer.

From a purely economic standpoint, the format is already a success for FOCUS online and Burda Publishing. The goal was to build user loyalty—to get users to spend more time in the app. But for Deutschländer, another benefit is even more important: the quality of the discussion.

A few months after the launch of “Debatte,” the editorial team noticed something: the comments were becoming more substantive. Apparently, readers appreciate having their voices heard. And so they make an effort to contribute interesting perspectives. While this phenomenon is difficult to measure with data, many on the editorial team share this impression. More than once, a reader’s perspective has sparked a follow-up article.

Pascal Deutschländer

If I ever got feedback like, “Hey, ‘The Debate’ made me think about the topic in a whole new way!”—that would be the greatest success for me.

Pascal Deutschländer, GenAI Product Manager at Burda Media

Creating a format where people can truly engage in discussion, where journalists listen to their readers instead of just the other way around, and where different perspectives are explored—that was also a very personal motivation for Deutschländer. “I’m from Thuringia,” he says. “There, I’ve seen how difficult political discussions have become in some cases. Many topics are discussed in a highly polarized way, and positions are quickly divided into two camps. The discussions are often black-and-white, even though public opinion is actually much more diverse.”

He explains that social division is also a concern for the FOCUS Online editorial team. “Of course, this is a major societal problem that we, as a publishing house, cannot solve on our own. But we want to do our part through initiatives like this one.”

Three Steps for Addressing Sensitive Topics

A difficult task. “The Debate” is meant to provide an honest snapshot of public sentiment, not to fuel division, but to provide a space for constructive comments—and, of course, to be read. However, it’s not the most level-headed perspective that gets the most clicks, but the most polemical one. Filtering out trolls and hateful comments isn’t a problem—AI can handle that on its own—but how do you strike a balance between attracting attention and maintaining objectivity?

“That’s actually not an easy question,” says Deutschländer. He and his colleagues have introduced three levels to which they categorize the discussions. Level 1 consists of light topics, such as sports. For those, the headline can certainly be a bit more eye-catching.

Level 2 covers topics like finance. “Clickbait isn’t necessary here,” explains Deutschländer. “In debates like these, there are usually really strong arguments, and the Google algorithm picks up on the articles anyway.” Every now and then, however, emotions can and do run a little high even here—for example, when it comes to tax reform: “Damn it, start saving at home!” reads a reader quote in the headline.

Level 3 consists of critical topics, such as asylum policy. Here, the editorial team must carefully weigh the options each time: How emotionally charged should we make the piece? Is a “debate” article even worthwhile, or is it the wrong format for this complex topic? The editorial team may omit some topics entirely, while for others, the headline is phrased more neutrally to emphasize that it is an expression of opinion. For example, “Readers Criticize the Handling of Islamism” or “Readers Debate Sweden’s Immigration Policy.”

Another important tool is the “opinion poll,” in which readers are asked a question about the article. For Deutschländer, it’s very important that this not be a yes-or-no decision, because in most discussions there isn’t a simple either-or answer. Together with the editorial team, he develops more in-depth questions that can be answered on a scale.

The Goal is to Create New Perspectives

Features like the barometer help give a voice to more reserved readers. After all, while most people read comments, they don’t comment themselves. When people can express their opinion with just one click, they’re more likely to feel confident—and may even be encouraged—to write a comment.

“I’d like to see even more diverse perspectives,” says Deutschländer. He notes that the FOCUS Online community tends to be conservative, so it would be interesting to be able to incorporate other opinions.

And then Deutschländer describes his vision of success: “If I ever received feedback like, ‘Hey, “The Debate” made me think about the topic in a whole new way!’—that would be the greatest success for me.”

Bannerbild: Screenshot / www.focus.de

About the author

Bernadette Mittemeier

newsletter

Want to know more about media innovations at the location?

Stay up to date with the latest articles and event tips sent directly to your email.